GPT-6.2 Astra vs Claude Fable 5.2: The 6.6x Bill Has a Catch
Fable's Max benchmark bill is 6.6x Astra's. Lower the effort and the gap shrinks. See which saving survives human review and cached pricing.

At maximum effort, Fable's extra three Intelligence Index points come with a bill 6.6 times as large per benchmark task. Artificial Analysis lists GPT-6.2 Astra at 62 and $4.00, against Claude Fable 5.2 at 65 and $26.54. Fable has default fallback enabled. Astra profile, Fable profile, checked November 21.
Now turn Fable down to High. Its listed bill falls to $9.08, with a rounded index score of 62, the same displayed score as Astra at Max. The closer-score price gap is $5.08, or about five minutes of a reviewer's time at $60 per hour. Artificial Analysis's effort-level comparison makes that setting worth testing before assuming Astra saves you the full $22.54.
Try Astra first on a job with a clear pass condition. Give Fable the same job at an effort level you would actually pay for. Make the more expensive option earn its premium through more usable results or less correction. Our calculations use the published benchmark data and hypothetical review times.
Where each model earns its place
Here are three separate tests, comparing Astra Max with Fable Max using Default Fallback. The bills are for running the benchmark tasks.
- Broad capability. Astra scored 62 at $4.00 per task. Fable scored 65 at $26.54. AA Intelligence Index
- Interactive browser scenes. Astra scored 1,318 Elo. Fable scored 1,271. AA-3D
- Legal deliverables. Astra scored 15.0% on the benchmark's strict all-pass measure at $6.35 per task. Fable scored 7.2% at $39.84 per task. Harvey LAB-AA v1.1
Astra has the higher measured 3D score and more than twice Fable's all-pass score on that legal test. Fable leads the broad Intelligence Index. Both models scored below 20% on the strict legal measure. A low bill needs an acceptable deliverable attached to it.
Artificial Analysis's index methodology explains the composite, while its model profiles explain the weighted task cost. That cost combines input, cache, reasoning and answer charges across evaluations. It is an average cost to run the tests, rather than the cost of a task a human approved. Dividing $26.54 by $4 gives 6.6 times the execution cost for Fable in this comparison.
At High, Fable costs about 2.3 times Astra Max's $4.00. The shared rounded score can hide differences that matter to your workload. The same benchmark score could make sense for a browser demo and give you little guidance on fixing a production bug.
How many minutes can erase the saving?
Suppose a real task reproduced the benchmark's $4.00 versus $26.54 API bills. Both outputs pass eventually. Your reviewer costs $60 per hour, or $1 per minute. This is a hypothetical decision example, not a measured Astra trial.
If Fable needs five minutes of review, its combined cost is $31.54. Astra could consume 27.54 minutes of review before reaching the same total: $4 + $27.54. That leaves Astra 22.54 extra minutes, roughly 22 minutes 32 seconds, to spend correcting its answer.
Now give Astra a messy handoff that takes 30 minutes to repair. Its total becomes $34. Fable's $31.54 is cheaper, despite the much higher API bill. Give Astra a clean output that needs the same five-minute check, and its $9 total wins comfortably.
Use the difference in review time, because both answers need checking. The break-even formula is:
extra review minutes affordable = API saving / reviewer cost per minuteAt $120 per hour, the same API gap buys only 11.27 extra minutes. At $30 per hour, it buys 45.08. Substitute your actual labor cost and measured API bills. A result that fails acceptance entirely needs a replacement attempt counted too; more editing time cannot always rescue it.
That gives the model choice a concrete test. Can Astra finish the job within the review budget its lower bill buys? Can Fable save enough correction work to cover its premium? Those are decisions a team can audit after one small batch.
Repeat the calculation for Fable High's $9.08 benchmark bill and Astra Max's $4.00. The $5.08 gap buys 5.08 extra review minutes at the same labor rate. A six-minute correction would erase it if everything else were equal. Choosing the effort setting changes the business case before either model touches your task.
Start with a job whose mistakes you can see
For a browser prototype, Astra has evidence worth acting on. AA-3D uses blind human comparisons of interactive scenes. Its individual score intervals for Astra and Fable overlap slightly; that alone does not establish the significance of their difference. Open the same brief in both models' outputs using our AA-3D demos and comparison. Judge the interaction you need, then inspect the code and performance separately.
For code review, GitHub reports that Astra found more issues than GPT-6 Astra in early testing and used fewer tokens on agentic coding tasks. That makes review a reasonable trial candidate. GitHub distributes the models through Copilot, and the announcement supplies neither a public dataset nor a numerical Astra score. It does not compare Astra with Fable.
Make that trial assessable: use a small public or synthetic patch with known defects and count valid findings, missed defects and false alarms. A review full of plausible but incorrect warnings spends the human budget quickly. Our early coding review analysis explains why finding bugs and owning an extended build are different assignments.
For a hard research problem, Fable's stronger broad index result may justify paying more. Artificial Analysis's November 17 assessment also places Fable ahead in physics reasoning, factual knowledge and HLE-Diamond. That report found no Astra improvement over its predecessor on the Coding Agent Index. Keep the reported long-run failures in view before turning a cheap successful review into permission for an unattended project.
ARC Prize shows how much the test setup matters. GPT-6.2 Astra scored 100% on ARC-AGI-3 at Xhigh with a provider adapter that carries reasoning state across requests. The leaderboard lists about $4,100 in total for that run. Under the standard setup, Astra Max scored 70.3% and Fable 5.2 Xhigh scored 81.2%. ARC Prize notes that the Fable result used an earlier checkpoint. Record the test setup and effort level alongside the score when comparing models.
The Harvey result covers 120 private tasks across 24 legal practice areas. For each task, the benchmark counts the share of AI judges who found that every criterion was met. A material hallucination gives the task a zero. The final score averages those results across tasks. Treat it as evidence for further evaluation under expert review. Original evaluation.
The cache-price catch
Both models list the same short-context base rates. The receipts diverge when the token counts, cache hits or processing choices differ. These direct vendor prices were rechecked November 21.
Per million tokens, both charge $8 for uncached input and $40 for output. Cache hits cost $0.40 for Astra and $0.20 for Fable at standard rates.
Cache writes and retention are separate. The example assumes both caches are already warm. OpenAI pricing and Anthropic pricing.
Take a hypothetical request with 10,000 uncached input tokens, 90,000 cache-hit tokens and 10,000 billable output tokens. Excluding cache creation, tools, retries, regional premiums and review, Astra costs $0.516 and Fable $0.498. Fable wins that small price comparison because its cache hits cost less.
The difference is $0.018. At $40 per million output tokens, Astra must use 450 fewer billable output tokens just to tie: 9,550 instead of Fable's assumed 10,000. Its $0.116 input bill plus $0.382 output bill then equals Fable's $0.498. A larger output saving would make Astra cheaper, provided the result still passes review. These are calculated break-even counts, not measured model outputs; tokenizers can count the same text differently.
Keep processing conditions attached to the figures. Both vendors list Batch input/output rates of $4/$20 and Fast rates of $16/$80; availability and operating conditions differ. Astra's model pricing notes apply higher rates above 272,000 input tokens to the full request. Anthropic lists standard Fable rates across its full million-token context. A long cached conversation can therefore produce a different answer from the short-context table.
Fable's benchmark configuration also enables Default Fallback. Anthropic's original documentation describes retrying some refusals on another recommended model. Preserve that setting in a comparison record; the label does not disclose how frequently it ran in these evaluations.
What to do: bring a receipt to the next model decision
Choose one repeated job, define a pass before running it, and give both models equivalent tools and inputs. A useful pass describes the deliverable: all required facts extracted, specified defects found without invented warnings, or a prototype whose requested controls work. Save the first output before requesting repairs.
For each job, keep the API bill across all attempts, the review minutes and the final acceptance result. Include abandoned attempts. Compare outputs without model labels where practical, so an expensive model has to earn its reputation on the work in front of the reviewer.
Use two totals: spend per accepted result and review time per accepted result. A hypothetical Astra batch costing $80 with 16 accepted tasks and a Fable batch costing $100 with 20 both come to $5 per accepted task before labor. Fable delivers four more useful results. The smaller total invoice alone would have hidden that difference.
Then apply the break-even calculation to the jobs both models completed. Move the jobs where Astra clears your quality bar within the extra review time its saving permits. Keep Fable on jobs where it earns more accepted results or saves enough correction work. The GPT-6.2 migration checklist supplies the broader checks before that choice becomes your team's default.


